Skip to content

Kurdistan Agora

Who Gets to Be Kurdish Enough?

Photo of the Article: Who Gets to Be Kurdish Enough?

Abstract

A single mispronounced word can lead others to question someone’s Kurdish identity. This essay examines how language fluency, birthplace, and political loyalty become tests of belonging, particularly for Kurds in the diaspora. It argues that welcoming learners and making room for different experiences and views can help keep the Kurdish language and culture alive.

Publication record

Author
Raman Abdullahi
Type
comment
Published in
Kurdistan Agora
Date
2026/11/18
Language
English

Language, birthplace, and political beliefs can connect people to Kurdish identity. But when they become tests of belonging, who gets left outside?
“How can you be Kurdish if you don’t speak Kurdish?”
It is a question that can sound straightforward. Language carries stories, humor, songs and ways of understanding the world that translation cannot fully preserve. Wanting younger generations to speak Kurdish is understandable. But there is a difference between encouraging someone to learn and telling them they do not belong until they do.
Who gets to decide whether another person is Kurdish enough?
The tests take different forms. Do you speak fluently? Were you born in Kurdistan? Do you know its history? Do you hold the “right” political opinions? Each question touches something meaningful. Together, however, they can turn identity into an examination that some people enter with advantages others never had.
A child raised in a Kurdish-speaking household has opportunities that a child raised without the language does not. Someone surrounded by relatives sharing stories about their hometown has a different connection to that place from someone whose family rarely discusses the past.
These differences should invite curiosity before judgment. Fluency does not explain everything about how someone grew up, what they were taught or what they are trying to recover. Consider what happens when a learner mispronounces a word. The listener can correct them patiently or laugh at them. That small choice can influence whether the learner tries again. A community concerned about its language’s future should make room for mistakes. Shame is a poor teaching method.
The birthplace creates another test. A Kurd born abroad may be treated as too distant to understand life in Kurdistan. Yet in the country where they grew up, they may still be asked where they are “really” from. Belonging becomes something they must repeatedly explain, unsure whether either answer will be accepted.
There are legitimate differences between living in Kurdistan and knowing it through family stories, visits, or news. Those experiencing local conditions every day have knowledge that deserves attention. A person abroad should listen carefully before claiming to speak for them.
Recognizing that difference does not require ranking people’s Kurdishness. Someone can belong to a person without having lived every version of that person’s life.
Political beliefs can make these boundaries sharper. When loyalty to a party or leader becomes a measure of identity, disagreement starts to look like betrayal. Little room remains for someone who questions inherited opinions or refuses to excuse wrongdoing simply because it comes from their own side. A shared identity cannot reasonably demand identical political conclusions. Debate should involve evidence, principles and consequences. Declaring someone insufficiently Kurdish avoids that debate instead of answering it.
The strongest objection to a more open understanding of belonging is that identity needs substance. If language, historical knowledge and participation become entirely optional, what keeps a culture alive? That concern deserves an answer. Cultural survival takes effort. Languages need speakers. Stories need listeners. Community organizations need people willing to contribute their time. Pride alone cannot do that work. But asking people to take responsibility for their heritage is different from making their belonging conditional on achievements they have not yet reached. Someone who speaks little Kurdish can begin learning. Someone unfamiliar with history can read and ask questions. Someone raised far away can build relationships with people whose experiences differ from their own. These commitments become easier when the starting point is welcome.
Belonging does not place anyone beyond criticism. Misinformation should be challenged, and harmful behavior should be questioned. Criticism can address what someone says or does without putting their entire identity on trial. A more useful question is what people do with the connection they have. Do they approach others respectfully? Are they willing to learn? Can they acknowledge gaps in their knowledge?
Those questions encourage growth. “Are you Kurdish enough?” encourages a defense.
The next time someone searches for a Kurdish word and gets it wrong, there is a choice. Their mistake can become evidence against them, or the beginning of a conversation. If the hope is for another generation to carry the language forward, that conversation is worth having.

TISHK on social media

More from Kurdistan Agora

See all
Kurdistan Agora

Broken and Suspended

In the essay "Broken and Suspended," international security analyst Shahin Modarres explores the paralyzed state of Iranian political society following the devastating Israeli and American military strikes of June 2025. Modarres argues that while the Islamic Republic is militarily shattered, the Iranian…